Collecting old coins can be a fun hobby, whether you’re doing it for the thrill of the hunt or hoping to cash in on a hidden gem. While not everyone will stumble upon an ultra-rare coin like the 1933 “Saint Gaudens” Double Eagle (which sold for almost $19 million), you could still find some state quarters that are worth more than their face value.
Before you toss that random quarter into a fountain or Coinstar, take a second look! Some quarters with unique errors, like raised lines or doubled designs, might be worth a lot more than 25 cents.
Here are 20 rare state quarters that could bring in extra cash, based on estimates from Gainesville Coins, USA CoinBook, and PCGS. Remember, most of these coins have errors, so their exact numbers are unknown. The values below are just estimates based on what’s been found so far.
8 Rare European Coins That Could Instantly Boost Your Bank Account!
1. 1999-P Delaware Spitting Horse Quarter
- Mintage: 774,824,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: $10 to $20
2. 2004-D Extra Leaf Wisconsin Quarter
- Mintage: 226,800,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: $50 (Extra Low Leaf) to $65 (Extra High Leaf)
3. 2005-P Minnesota Doubled Dies Quarter
- Mintage: 239,600,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: $5 to $100 (depending on the doubling severity)
4. 2009-D District of Columbia Doubled Die Quarter
- Mintage: 88,800,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: $75
5. 1999-S Pennsylvania Proof Silver Quarter
- Mintage: 804,565 (non-error)
- Estimated value: $35
6. 1999-S New Jersey Proof Silver Quarter
- Mintage: 804,565 (non-error)
- Estimated value: $30
7. 1999-D New Jersey Quarter
- Mintage: 299,028,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 87 cents to $5.84
This Secret Pattern Hidden in UK Coins Will Blow Your Mind – Here’s How to Spot It!
8. 2000-D South Carolina Quarter
- Mintage: 566,208,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 69 cents to $4.63
9. 2000-D New Hampshire Quarter
- Mintage: 495,976,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 69 cents to $4.63
10. 2001-D New York Quarter
- Mintage: 619,640,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 69 cents to $4.63
11. 2001-D North Carolina Quarter
- Mintage: 427,876,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 69 cents to $4.63
12. 2001-D Rhode Island Quarter
- Mintage: 447,100,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 69 cents to $4.63
13. 2003-P Maine Quarter
- Mintage: 217,400,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 69 cents to $1.76
14. 2004-P Michigan Quarter
- Mintage: 233,800,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 69 cents to $3.38
15. 2005-P Kansas Quarter
- Mintage: 263,400,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 46 cents to $5.84
16. 2005-D West Virginia Quarter
- Mintage: 356,200,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 46 cents to $5.84
Unlock Wealth: 15 American Coins Worth a Fortune!
17. 2006-D North Dakota Quarter
- Mintage: 359,000,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 46 cents to $2.33
18. 2006-D South Dakota Quarter
- Mintage: 265,800,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 46 cents to $2.33
19. 2008-D New Mexico Quarter
- Mintage: 244,400,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 46 cents to $2.33
20. 2008-P Arizona Quarter
- Mintage: 244,600,000 (non-error)
- Estimated value: 46 cents to $2.33
How To Know If Your State Quarter Is Valuable
Wondering if you’ve got a valuable state quarter? These coins usually fetch higher prices if they have rare variations or errors, such as:
- Doubled dies: where parts of the design appear twice.
- Die cracks: cracks that appear due to damaged dies.
- Clipped planchets: pieces of the metal coin missing.
These errors can be small and easy to miss, so inspect your state quarters closely for any strange details. If you find one, you can keep it as a collectible or sell it to make some extra cash.
Where To Sell Rare Quarters
If you do find a rare quarter, you have several options for selling it:
- Auctions: Either online or at local coin shows.
- Coin dealers: Visit a shop or coin show in your area.
- Online platforms: Sites like eBay are a popular choice.
Ethan is a passionate rare coin collector with years of experience uncovering the stories and history behind unique coins. His insightful articles are a go-to for anyone curious about coin values or their fascinating backstories.